Steinberg and Prost focus on how Jews arrived in the American Midwest and innovated with local produce and foods. Breads used local ryes and were coated with cornmeal, baklava used local cranberries, dark pumpernickles were sprinkled with Iowa sunflower seeds and almonds, catsup was made with Michigan sour grapes, bourekas used Michigan cherries, and gefilte fish was made with Minnesota pike. The book opens in 1761 when Ezekiel Solomon of Berlin survived a Native American massacre and opens a general store. Over the decades more Jewish traders settled in the Midwest and the authors paint an interesting picture of the difficult overland trips and foods of the settlers (horse meat and grass seed). After the Civil War and the additional waves of immigration, with improved transportation and preservation, the authors show how Jews adapted and adopted foods. The authors discuss how the Progressive Era German Jews and social workers attempted to train Jewish immigrants in “American” foodways, and how cookbooks, such as the Fanny Farmer Cookbook of 1896 and the 1901 (Jewish) Settlement cookbooks standardized recipes and cooking methods. Tracking recipes over time, the authors show how brisket and beef a la mode recipes reduced their number of spices needed as a reaction to changing duties and prices, the fear of bacteria, and the abandonment of “fancified French” styles. Fanny Farmer used only salt and pepper.
In terms of old midwestern recipes (by the way, there was no notion of the “MidWest” at this time), there are Matzophon (like matza brei but with milk); Rhodes-style Peskada con de Tomat, which uses Lake Michigan fish; pcikled vegetables; Torshi; Uma Damla; Friscada; Pot Roasts, Potato Cake; Sweet and Sour Beans; Chow-Chow; pickles; Tomato Relish; Kuchen; Caramels; Matzos Charlotte; Brisket with Onions and Raisins; Persian Charoset; Red Horseradish Sauce; Potato Flour Sponge Cake; Fruit Cake; Prune Pie; Strauben (Dough Nuts); Mock Strudel; Blintz Batter; Borekas; Hucklebery Pie (Huckleberries were very popular); and various styles of pie crusts (graham, crumb). Reading the sparse, abbreviated recipes takes you back to a time when everything was made from scratch, and women had maintained homes with eight or more children.
As they sang in Yiddish:
Zuntik – bulbes, Montik – bulbes!
Dinstik uhn Mitvoch – Bulbes!
Dohnershtik uhn Fraytik – Bulbes!
Ober Shabbes nokhn tsholnt a bulbe kigele!
Uhn Zuntik vayter Bulbes.
(Sunday – Potatoes, Monday – potatoes, Tuesday and Wednesday Potatoes. Thuirday and Driday, Potatoes, But the treat on Shabbos is a potato kugel, And Sunday, once again, potatoes.)