So this was my first GA… The General Assembly – The Superbowl of Judaism in all of its glory, in Nashville, Tennessee.
I arrived at this enormous hotel – The Gaylord Opryland Hotel Resort and Convention Center, but it might as well have been the Miami Orange Bowl. I checked in – “Nice hotel room!” I thought. “Remember, to thank the UJC for such a lovely overseas invitation.”
Later, I walked half way across the hotel – past this Christian Zionist convention that was also taking place there and Jews young and old began to appear. They were draped in blue name tags – pins with the Israeli and American flags intertwined and Little Debbie Oatmeal Cream Pies in hand. These treats were available free everywhere within the GA – Don’t ask! I was honored with a customized name tag festooned with a blue ribbon hanging from the pin titled “Speaker” and a yellow one titled “Press.” As I passed by my fellow super Jews, I received nods of recognition – The honor of being a GA speaker.
I managed to sneak my way in to the Opening Plenary which was titled “One People, One Destiny” – A spiel on the collective Federation system’s ability to do a world of good. I heard from inspirational US and Israeli leaders about the impact of community volunteerism and teamwork. Both my countries’ national anthems are sung and then one of the highlight of the plenary stepped onto the stage – Chair of the Democratic Committee: Howard Dean. Dean made a political speech accusing Republicans of being less diverse than the Democratic Party, but I wasn’t feeling it. Israeli Foreign Minister Tzipi Livni, who was scheduled to speak that afternoon, canceled her visit because of her responsibilities as the chief negotiator with the Palestinians. I wasn’t surprised. She was replaced by Isaac Herzog, minister of Welfare and Social Services, who spoke about the upcoming Mid East Peace Summit in Annapolis, calling it a “golden opportunity,” stressing that Israel is taking a “sober” approach to the summit.
I spent the next 24-48 hours shmoozing. Part of that involved meeting other young Jewish leaders – though I have to say we were few in numbers. I ate corned beef with JAFI Foreign Press spokesman Michael Jankelowitz and dozens of other Journalism majors from various U.S. Universities. I spoke on a panel for JAFI’s “Do the Write Thing Program,” along with Jewish World Affairs correspondent for the JPost, Haviv Rettig. He’s awesome! I shared with budding cub reporters what it has been like to be a journalist in Israel and how in G-ds name I even acquired such a position.
I had several wonderful reunions with my fellow ROI 120ers like Esther Kustanowitz, Ahava Zarembski, Todd Schechter and Michael Novack…
I ran into some of my favorite Jewish communal leaders including the UJC’S Israel Director, Nachman Shai – (who I sat next to Nashville to NY on my way home, but that’s a whole other story) and Director General for Aliyah and Klitah at the Jewish Agency, Oded Salomon, Ophir Pines, Chair of the Knesset Internal Affairs and Environment Committee, and the list goes on and on and on…
I popped into various breakout sessions and plenaries including: “A New Approach to Investing in Israel,” A screening of the delightfully handsome Ari Sandel’s film “West Bank Story,” (An Academy Award Winner, By the way!) Quite hilarious actually… It features forbidden love between Israeli soldier David and the Palestinian Fatima.
I then headed out into “the Nash” for some good ole country classic fun, though I didn’t take it to the full frontal level of Pork Ribs and table top dancers. What a fun city with a whole lotta spice and spunk. But I don’t think the city has any Jews (I mean I know that they do, but not even sure where.) The Nash probably never saw so many Jews, or Israelis for that matter, converge on their itty bitty city…EVER!
By the last day of the trip, my jet lag was starting to take its toll and on top of that I still had the trans-Atlantic ride home to look forward to. The whole purpose of my flying half way across the world had nonetheless arrived – the last day was when I would speak on a breakout session about Jewish Peoplehood, appropriately titled “Young Jewish Leaders Explore Peoplehood.” Until this gig, I was never really sure what Peoplehood meant. After much research and picking the brain of every Jew I knew, I was able to draw my own conclusions and came up with a pretty descent speech. Others on my panel were David Bryfman, an NYU Ph.D Candidate – the audience just loved him – he even got a couple of standing ovations. Esther Kustanowitz of Jewlicious – and Senior Editor of PresenTense Magazine was the next speaker (Note: I’m a big fan of her now!). Next, there was Ahava Zerembski, Founder and President of the Yesod-Masad Initiative.
When it was my turn I had 2 minutes to convince the room that I had something meaningful and moving to say. I began with my definition of Peoplehood – which to me is a comprehensive sense of belonging to Judaism – Not Judaism uniquely as a religion or history or ethnicity or culture – Judaism simply as a whole; I spoke of my struggle to find Jewish Peoplehood outside of Israel and how even as a religious and secular Jew in America, I felt I had zero connection. I revealed my path of finding Peoplehood in Israel and though I am still unable to articulate what in fact it is – I do feel it here. How can you not when you live, sleep and breath it in the Holyland? Historically I feel it as I walk through the old city walls. In terms of culture and Nationality, I live within the framework of the Jewish Calendar – Now the holidays are my national holidays. I see my fellow black hat Jews everyday on the street. I concluded with the opportunities Peoplehood has afforded me. Finding my peoplehood meant finding a career – finding my life’s purpose and wanting to educate the world on all I have learned and love. The last point I brought home in the form of a trailer for a film I am working on along with Jaron Gilinsky, Elad Gefen and Yosef Adest titled: Destination: Zion:
Then our panel was cut short for the one and only Condeleeza Rice whose security team really shook the city (and the hotel especially) up – well you can just imagine. Condi said that she believed most Israelis would give up most of the West Bank in exchange for peace. Rice said Israelis today believe that the establishment of a responsible Palestinian state would be to their benefit, and that most Arab countries no longer ask whether Israel will exist, but what the conditions for peace are. Rice also added that everyone had waited too long for peace and urged forward movement.
After her speech I headed home feeling a little wiser, a bit more connected and at peace. It was a comfort to me to see at least a handful of Jews dedicated to Jewish Unity and the future and survival of Israel and the Jewish people at large. This was especially comforting given a survey I had read days earlier that stated that according to North American, non orthodox Jews aged 18-35, “It wouldn’t really be a big deal, if Israel ceased to exist.”
Now that’s scary.
On my El Al Flight home from JFK to Tel Aviv I sat amidst an Evangelical Christian tour to the Holyland. Me and 60 Christians and a Black Hat Haredi Jew sitting to my right. When we got to our seats on the plane… the Haredi and I just looked over at one another and smiled. At that moment, I felt peoplehood in all its glory. Though he and I were completely different, we both felt like family – especially given the company.
Get to next year’s GA – Scheduled to be held November 2008, in Jerusalem, Israel!
- Taking A Flying Leap: Skydiving over Israel - 7/15/2009
- Reporting From the Gaza Border - 1/7/2009
- Operation Cast Lead: Going Into Gaza - 1/4/2009
Levitra Effetti Collaterali https://newfasttadalafil.com/ – where to buy cialis cheap buy cialis generic online During this time your tendon grows back together. https://newfasttadalafil.com/ – cheap cialis online pharmacy Medicament Levitra Gwtgyi
Tamar,
I apologize if I offended you or anyone else who lives or comes from one of my favorite new American cities. I realize that many lovely Jews live in Nashville… I unfortunately did not have the opportunity to meet them all. The locals, both non Jewish and Jewish alike were nothing but warm and friendly…Something I am not used to seeing as much in Israel and with Israelis. If you do ever come to my part of the world, please know that you are always welcome to stay with me…And Jon C. as well. Thank you for keeping me on my toes.
Tamar,
great post, couldn’t agree more……
Oh my,
Tamar! I am certain that Leah did not intend to diss you or Nashville at all. Don’t think for a second that I forgot your kind offer of food and hospitality for our poor hungry students at the GA. Y’all might have a relatively small community but if you are even remotely representative then clearly your heart and spirit have no bounds. If you do come to Israel, please let us know using the contact form and we would be thrilled to repay you for your community’s kindness and hospitality!
Tamar,
Like leah, I too was at the GA in your lovely city. While I am somewhat older than her I would like to think that I am attuned to your concerns. I won’t discuss partisan political issues but I agree that the GA and the underlying Federations have been doing a very bad job attracting new blood and addressing issues relevant to youth and their inclusion. Look at what they did to the otherwise much admired mobius who used to rail against the failings of the organized Jewish community and criticized Israel for what he perceived to be her apartheid like behavior towards the Palestinians and heavy handed tactics of its security forces against internal dissent. The once proud “Orthodox Anarchist” has sold out, praising the system he once opposed and reduced to delivering a well rehearsed pre-approved speech where he essentially begs us all to give him money. The Federation systen eats its young and as a member of that system, I am sorry for failing you. You do have a lovely city though and the Jews of Nashville were very kind and hospitable, I am sure Leah would concur.
Take a number.
😉
” But I don’t think the city has any Jews (I mean I know that they do, but not even sure where.) The Nash probably never saw so many Jews, or Israelis for that matter, converge on their itty bitty city…EVER!”
Listen, I hate to do this, but could you sound any more self-centered? There are more than 7000 Jews in Nashville, and I’m not sure what we are supposed to do –wear signs so you know who we are? And Nashville isn’t an “itty bitty city”–there are more than half a million people living within the city limits, and tons more in the burbs.
The GA, while fascinating in many ways, is not exactly the highlight of my year. Mostly, it’s a bunch of rich funders hanging around talking about how to get more people to donate to federations. They only focus on getting the next generation involved now because they’ve been doing such a crappy job of reaching the people in my age bracket up until this point. And while I think Mobius is great and I admire the UJC’s commitment to trying to do better by young people, I am hardly interested in investing in an organization that invites Condi Rice to speak.
You’ll have to forgive us young active Jews in Nashville if we didn’t get down on our knees and thank God for the gift that was the GA. If I come to Israel I hope you won’t mind if I generalize and condescend to the entire country. It’s only fair.
Oh, I grew up in Miami too, so I was thinking it might be something clever or an inside joke for Miamians.
Ofri, it’s apparently a chain of hotels. They’ve got one in Florida and somewhere else too, I think…
Well, Leah Stern grew up in Miami where they have this huge stadium called th Orange Bowl. The Gaylord Opryland is similarly huge.
Not quite so funny – especially when you have to explain it…
Can someone explain the Orange Bowl “joke”?
I promise there are Jews in Nashville… Just not too many. I’m a local college student and was privileged to attend the GA. I have to say I really enjoyed it, and was impressed with many of the speakers. I agree with you on the Howard Dean note, and thanks for clearing up why Tzipi Livni didn’t make it!
ck, you can’t hide that accent 🙂
Gaylord Opryland? Really?
I am shepping such naches! Did I say that right? Both you and Esther did a great job – the GA organizers made a great choice in inviting you both to address the GA. Next year in Jerusalem!
Nice comprehensive and colorful report on the GA! Especially enjoyed the trailer for Destination Zion…
“This was especially comforting given a survey I had read days earlier that had stated that according to North American, non orthodox Jews aged 18-35, “It wouldn’t really be a big deal, if Israel ceased to exist.â€
Given the education students are getting at loony-left North American Universities Leah, you should find it comforting younger Jews didn’t feel “It wouldn’t be a big deal, if we joined the Palestinians in speeding up the process.”
Glad you liked Haviv, he is a real star. Looks like you got some good stuff there.
Amir