Noam_shalit.jpgGilad Schalit has been in Palestinian captivity for almost 2 years. Typical of Israeli POWs in Arab hands, almost nothing has been heard from him, save for one recording, nobody outside of his captors has been permitted to visit him even once and also typically, the demands to exchange him border on the ludicrous with Hamas asking for the release of hundreds of Palestinian prisoners including terrorists and terrorist abetters.

The code phrase is “blood on their hands.” Some terrorists who have been directly and indirectly involved in attacks on Israelis, particularly Israeli civilians, are considered to be un-freeable. There are some reasons for this beyond political considerations, namely the concern that they will revert to their previous terrorist activities even if they sign a promissory document that they won’t. The political sensitivity is no less of an issue because any Israeli PM willing to sign off on a deal that appears too generous will have to contend with appearing to be weak and with an even greater price for the two Israelis in Hizbullah’s captivity.

Hanging over the entire difficult enterprise is the Ron Arad story. Ron Arad was a navigator who ejected from his plane in Lebanese territory in the mid-80s and was captured alive. He is still suspected to be alive 22 years later, but has not been seen and outside of a couple of old videos, not been heard from for two decades. Nobody wants to be responsible for another Ron Arad. The Arad story also brings into relief the other concern here which is that when you have a conscript army and any soldier could be kidnapped or taken hostage, you have to take steps to reassure your population that such soldiers will not be left behind and that the military and government will attempt to bring them back with an understanding that the price will be high.

Gilad Schalit’s father, Noam, is a mild-mannered, intelligent man who has been watching his son’s fate play out to the conflicting needs of Israel and its politicians as well as Hamas and its militants. He has been getting more and more vocal over time, perhaps feeling desperation about his son’s circumstances. He lashed out a couple of days ago at Olmert and the IDF. He challenged them to do more and berated them for an inability to make tough decisions and to protect their soldiers, respectively. He asked why his son, Gilad, was the only “fryer” – roughly translating to “sucker” – to pay a price for the IDF’s incompetence. Specifically, why was nobody else in the chain of command punished for their incompetence in the Shalit kidnapping.

This is a good question and one that I asked in June of 2006 when Shalit was captured. At the time, I was concerned that even with forewarning about the pending attack, the IDF still couldn’t get its soldiers to protect themselves. The entire kidnapping scenario was a fiasco, with intelligence available that indicated where the attack was likely to come, but somehow with Shalit’s force putting its resources in the direction opposite that from which the Hamas attack came. It was amateur hour at best, and at the time I expressed concern that the IDF leadership may simply not be up to par. A couple of months later, the second Lebanon war showed us that what happened near Gaza with Shalit was symptomatic of a much deeper problem in the IDF.

The Jerusalem Post is reporting that yesterday a group of bereaved parents of fallen Israelis who were killed by terror responded angrily to Noam Shalit’s comments and criticism.

In a statement released by the Almagor terror victims organization the parents said that “For the first time since the Second Lebanon War they are aligning themselves with Prime Minister [Ehud Olmert] and rejecting Schalit’s demand that convicted Palestinian murderers be released in exchange for his son.”

“Your son is not the only sucker in the country and isn’t the only one who pays the price for its security,” the bereaved father wrote. “Our son Aviad fell in Gaza while pursuing terrorists and I am willing to trade places with you at any moment. Give me back my son and I’ll promise that I won’t demand that others be murdered for his sake.”

The letter goes on to warn that any prisoner exchange deal that included the release of prisoners “with blood on their hands” would “not only hurt the bereaved families but will lead to more bereaved parents and more parents of kidnapped soldiers.”

The letter claimed that “Previous such deals have caused the killings of 180 Israeli citizens over the past five years.”

Oy! Hamas must be enjoying the spectacle and the division among Israelis.

Sometimes, there are fewer tougher jobs than being Israel’s PM. This is one issue where I wouldn’t want to be sitting in Olmert’s chair.

About the author



  • While I feel for the Shalit family’s excruciating reality, his (Noam’s) actions are effectively proliferating exactly the evil that happened to them.

    Israel has so unfortunately exchanged *large* numbers of terrorist prisoners in exchange for the release of their hostages. Well, gee… I wonder what the best way to motivate terrorists to take more Israeli hostages in the future is?!?!

    The politicians who are entrusted in the position of power to be the ultimate decision-makers MUST RESIST THE TEMPTATION (or cowardice) to solve the short-term crisis even though they could miss the credit (or the blame). For the sake of Israel = it’s population, A CLEAR AND ABSOLUTE POLICY THAT HOSTAGES WILL NEVER YIELD A REWARD – EVER. Not in this administration, nor the next, nor the… Only then will the enticement to take Israeli hostages be minimized.

  • During the Second Lebanon War, I sent an email home telling my friends and family that, in the event I were ever kidnapped by terrorists, by no means should I be swapped for terrorists.

    I mean, I am important, but not that important….

    At the same time, I cannot imagine what the families of the kidnapped soldiers are enduring right now, or the soldiers themselves. It is always easy to be noble when it is theoretical.

  • I think that the army probably has a very good idea where Shalit is, but pretty much know that he’ll get a bullet to the head until someone from Sayeret Matkal gets near. Getting there to scoop up his body (chas v’shalom) might include killing dozens of terrorists and of course while risking special ops forces on the ground as well (a very important halachic requirement requires risking a lot for even one single Jew) nonetheless.

    But almost two years have gone by and we already know that Kadima can’t think out of the box. They’ve sent the media many a trial balloon about ‘prisoner’ swaps, all of which have simply equated the Arab murderers with our tank soldier, each time trying to see if the public will accept letting ‘blood on the hands’ terrorists free. Just recently, Israel had the momentum rolling with a massive operation to stop the Kassams (then downgraded to reduce the Kassams) in which dozens of Gazans sacrificed their lives to fight our soldiers mano-to-mano and what did Kadima do? They merely pulled back our soldiers to give them showers without sending a replacement battalion to keep up the pressure.

    Hamas was crying for help, the Arab media was raising hell, but the world was not and Kadima/Olmert gave mercy, just like it did in Lebanon in Summer 2006. Kadima/Olmert have the same standard Israeli inferiority complex of being scared what the goyim will say on CNN and BBC.

    If Kadima were to think out of the box, and I pray that at any given time I’ll be surprised, they’ll send in special ops to kidnap a significant terrorist that would be a good enough trading card while immediate communications open to wheel and deal before the media (and us) finds out too. This would be the thing out of the movies in which we could get back our soldier and give them back some terrorist loser, even with blood on the hands. But to give up 200 murders for Gilad, (or me if I ever get to that place) no.

  • You really make it seem so easy with your presentation but I find this matter to be actually something that I think I would never understand. It seems too complicated and extremely broad for me. I’m looking forward for your next post, I will try to get the hang of it!

  • Title

    […]that would be the finish of this report. Right here you will find some sites that we think you’ll enjoy, just click the hyperlinks over[…]

  • Title

    […]always a significant fan of linking to bloggers that I love but really don’t get a good deal of link adore from[…]

  • Title

    […]always a big fan of linking to bloggers that I appreciate but really don’t get a good deal of link love from[…]

  • Title

    […]the time to study or visit the material or web sites we’ve linked to below the[…]

  • Title

    […]Every as soon as in a while we decide on blogs that we study. Listed beneath would be the most up-to-date web-sites that we select […]

  • Title

    […]please pay a visit to the websites we follow, including this one, because it represents our picks from the web[…]

  • Title

    […]we prefer to honor numerous other world wide web web pages around the net, even when they aren’t linked to us, by linking to them. Beneath are some webpages really worth checking out[…]

  • Title

    […]we like to honor quite a few other online web sites around the net, even when they aren’t linked to us, by linking to them. Under are some webpages worth checking out[…]