

Last Friday, Rabbi Dov Lior, the former chief rabbi of Kiryat Arba (the settlement next to Hebron), issued a halachic ruling, meaning a ruling on Jewish religious law, that Jews are allowed to harvest olives from Palestinian land in the West Bank. His reasoning, as reported by the Times of Israel: the Jewish people never gave up their claim to the Land of Israel, Arabs never bought the land from Jews, so it’s stolen property in their hands, and picking the olives is a way of fulfilling the commandment to conquer the land. According to Anadolu, the ruling was published by Channel 13 and isn’t limited to groves near settlements. It covers Palestinian land farther away too.
If you don’t know Lior, here’s the short version. He is one of the most prominent religious authorities in the settler movement. He called Baruch Goldstein, who murdered 29 Palestinians at prayer in the Cave of the Patriarchs in 1994, “as holy as the martyrs of the Holocaust.” In 2011 police briefly arrested him over his endorsement of Torat HaMelech, a book arguing Jewish law permits killing non-Jews in certain circumstances. This is not a random guy with a blog.
Israel Police say they are examining a complaint filed over the ruling. Good.
The halacha is not on his side
Tzohar, a group of moderate Religious Zionist rabbis, answered him directly: “theft is forbidden from anyone, Jew or non-Jew alike.” They added that private individuals don’t get to decide on their own to seize other people’s property.
They’re right, and it isn’t close. The Rambam (Maimonides, the most important codifier of Jewish law) rules in the Mishneh Torah that it is forbidden to rob anyone of anything, and he says explicitly that this includes an idolater. A Palestinian farmer is not even that. And even if you take the commandment to conquer the land as seriously as Lior does, Jewish law treats war and conquest as things a nation does through its legitimate authority. It does not hand that commandment to a teenager from a hilltop outpost with a bucket and a stick.
Stealing is stealing. Dressing it up as a mitzvah makes it worse, not better.
What the week actually looked like
The ruling landed in the middle of the worst year of settler violence on record, during the olive harvest, which is always a flashpoint.
On October 16 in the village of Abu Falah, northeast of Ramallah, masked settlers set olive groves on fire and threw rocks at Palestinian harvesters. A group of journalists about 80 yards away got chased down. One of them was Heidi Levine, a 64-year-old veteran photographer freelancing for the Washington Post, wearing a flak jacket marked PRESS. According to her daughter, she ended up with a broken rib, multiple fractured vertebrae and a finger that needed surgery. The Post’s executive editor, Matt Murray, put it plainly: “She was clearly beaten.” US Ambassador Mike Huckabee, who is about as pro-settlement as an American official gets, called it a “despicable act of terror” and demanded arrests.
The next day, in the Christian village of Taybeh, masked settlers attacked a delegation that included Belgium’s consul general, French and Polish diplomats and Catholic representatives. They beat Bernard Baudoux, the 78-year-old mayor of the French town of Aulnoye-Aymeries.
According to the Palestinian Health Ministry, at least four people have been killed and more than 100 injured since the harvest began this month.
Then came the excuses. Some have a kernel of truth. Most don’t. Here they are, graded.
Excuse 1: “It’s a handful of hilltop youth.”
This one is factually true. The IDF and the Shin Bet believe about 300 Jewish extremists are behind the attacks, with about 70 considered the hardcore. Most of the country, and most settlers, have nothing to do with it.
But think about what that means. Israel can find and kill a Hamas commander who took part in October 7. It did exactly that last week. It can’t find 70 kids it already has files on? According to the Institute for National Security Studies, about 94% of investigations into ideologically motivated crimes by Israelis in the West Bank between 2005 and 2025 were closed without an indictment. About 3% ended in a conviction.
Verdict: True, and worthless as a defense. A small group operating with near-total impunity is a policy failure, not an alibi.
Excuse 2: “Palestinians attack Jews too.”
Also true. In 2024 a 14-year-old Jewish shepherd, Binyamin Achimeir, was murdered while herding goats near the Malachei HaShalom outpost. The IDF recorded 1,015 Palestinian stone-throwing and Molotov cocktail incidents in 2025. The Binyamin Regional Council says there were 48 attacks on Jewish shepherds in a single week this month, though that’s the council’s own count and nobody has independently confirmed it. Jewish victims in the West Bank are real and they deserve better than being treated as a footnote.
None of that explains beating a 64-year-old photographer or a 78-year-old French mayor. Neither of them attacked anyone. And there’s a basic difference: Palestinian terrorism has an entire state apparatus hunting it every night. That’s how it should be. The complaint is that Jewish terrorism doesn’t.
Verdict: Valid context. Zero justification.
Excuse 3: “Serious questions remain.”
That’s what the Prime Minister’s Office said about Abu Falah. The statement claimed some 200 Arabs and far-left activists had confronted about 40 Israeli youths, and that both sides were hurling objects.
In principle, waiting for the facts before assigning blame is fine. In practice, the IDF condemned the incident, police opened an investigation, and Huckabee, not exactly a Peace Now guy, called it terror. And look at the wording. The masked, armed men are “Israeli youths.” The farmers and reporters are “Arabs and far-left activists.” You can tell whose side the questions are on.
Verdict: The process point is fair. The way it was used is spin.
Excuse 4: “The diplomats didn’t coordinate their visit.”
The IDF called the Taybeh attack a severe act of violence, then noted that the visit hadn’t been coordinated with the army and no soldiers were there.
So what? You don’t need a permit to not get beaten up. If anything, it’s an admission that a group of European diplomats can’t visit a Christian village in territory Israel controls without an army escort.
Verdict: Invalid.
Excuse 5: “Left-wing activists stage provocations and edit the footage.”
This month the Binyamin Regional Council launched a “Shepherd Camera Project” with a US Christian Zionist group called Generation Zion, putting police-style body cameras on Jewish farmers and shepherds so confrontations get documented.
Honestly? Good. Some activists do film selectively, and there are disputed incidents where the first viral clip turned out to be missing context. More cameras means more evidence, and evidence works in every direction. If a shepherd is innocent, the footage clears him. If a mob in masks burns an orchard, the footage convicts them.
Verdict: Sometimes true about specific incidents. Says nothing about these ones. The cameras are welcome.
Excuse 6: “It’s exaggerated, and it’s going down anyway.”
This summer the IDF spokesman claimed settler violence was dropping. Shin Bet figures published by Army Radio said the opposite: 660 attacks in the first half of 2026, up roughly 60% from the previous six months. The INSS, a mainstream Israeli security think tank, now calls it a strategic threat. Officers in Central Command say Jewish nationalist crime makes up as much as 80% of the log entries in some brigades, and that dealing with it has forced the army to cancel planned arrests of wanted Palestinians.
These are not UN numbers or NGO numbers. They’re ours.
Verdict: False.
Excuse 7: “It’s a police matter.”
On Monday, Defense Minister Israel Katz said settler violence should be handled entirely by the police, and that the army doesn’t support renewing administrative detention (jailing someone without charge or trial) for suspects.
There’s a real argument buried in there. Policing Israeli civilians is formally the police’s job, and administrative detention is an ugly tool I’d be happy to see used less on everyone. But Katz is the guy who cancelled administrative detention for settlers while keeping it for thousands of Palestinians, and who told a Likud crowd he doesn’t believe settlers commit terrorism at all. His words on the detention orders: “Not once did I sign for them.” Law enforcement officials have warned that losing that tool limits their ability to stop attacks. And handing everything to the police means handing it to the ministry run by Itamar Ben Gvir.
Verdict: Half a point on jurisdiction. Undercut entirely by who’s making it.
Bottom line
Lior’s ruling isn’t a stray opinion. It’s the theology the violence runs on: the land is ours, so whatever’s on it is ours, so taking it is holy. Tzohar answered him from the sources. Now the state has to answer him from the law, and so far it mostly hasn’t.
We’ve written about this before, in our pieces on Pinchas and on Qusra. It keeps getting worse because nobody pays a price. The election is in a week. Ask whoever wants your vote what they’re going to do about it.
Stealing is stealing. Beating a 78-year-old is beating a 78-year-old. None of this is complicated, and anyone telling you it is wants something from you.





